RUS  ENG
Full version
JOURNALS // Matematicheskoe Modelirovanie i Chislennye Metody // Archive

Mat. Mod. Chisl. Met., 2014 Issue 1, Pages 131–144 (Mi mmcm10)

This article is cited in 1 paper

Disadvantages of citation index and Hirsch and using other scientometrics

A. D. Polyanin

A. Ishlinsky Institite for Problems in Mechanics, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow

Abstract: The paper deals with the citation index and h-index, which are the main scientometric indices, currently used for evaluating the performance of scientists and university profes-sors. The author indicates their main disadvantages and considers a number of illustra-tive examples. The study shows that the normalized citation index (taking into account the presence of co-authors) has a number of important advantages in comparison with other scientometric indices. The author proposes new indices — the maximum citation indices, which can be easily calculated, have a simple and clear interpretation and have a num-ber of distinct advantages in comparison with the h-index.

Keywords: Citation, scientometric indice, hirsch index, performance evaluation, the max-imum citation indexes.

UDC: 001.92

Received: 14.12.2013



© Steklov Math. Inst. of RAS, 2025